| Standings | MVP | Cy Young | Tony Ziccardi Award | Relief Award |
| 1921 | Babe Ruth, CIN | Urban Shocker, PUN | Jeff Cofield, LTL | Lou North, COR |
| 1922 | Ken Williams, BAK | Red Faber, ICM | Andrew Stevens, YOR | Lefty Weinert, YOR |
| 1923 | Babe Ruth, CIN (2) | Dolf Luque, NYN | Kevin Stillman, NYN | Johnny Cooney, COR |
| 1924 | Babe Ruth, CIN (3) | Dazzy Vance, BAN | Michael Sliger, CIN | Pete Donohue, YOR |
| 1925 | Rogers Hornsby, COR | Walter Johnson, NYN | Tom Cronk, COR | Freddie Fitzsimmons, BAN |
| 1926 | Lou Gehrig, NYN | Ray Kremer, NYN | Andrew Stevens, YOR (2) | Guy Bush, COR |
| 1927 | Lou Gehrig, NYN (2) | Lefty Grove, BAK | Kevin Stillman, NYN (2) | Fred Frankhouse, COR |
| 1928 | Jim Bottomley, BAK | Garland Braxton, YOR | Sean Cahill, BAK | Hal Haid, BAN |
| 1929 | Lou Gehrig, NYN (3) | Carl Hubbell, BAK | Mark Schantz, CHI | Ralph Judd, BRX |
| 1930 | Hack Wilson, CIN | Lefty Grove, BAK (2) | Mark Schantz, CHI (2) | Pete Appleton, LTL |
| 1931 | Babe Ruth, CIN (4) | Lefty Grove, BAK (3) | Randy Howard, ICM | Syl Johnson, CHI |
| 1932 | Jimmie Foxx, LTL | Red Ruffing, CHI | Jeff Cofield, LTL (2) | Ben Cantwell, LTL |
| 1933 | Jimmie Foxx, LTL (2) | Hal Schumacher, NYN | Tom Cronk, COR (2) | Joe Heving, BAN |
| 1934 | Lou Gehrig, NYN (4) | Hal Schumacher, NYN (2) | Kevin Stillman, NYN (3) | Jesse Haines, MIN |
| 1935 | Jimmie Foxx, LTL (3) | Lefty Grove, LTL (4) | Jeff Cofield, LTL (3) | Jesse Haines, LTL (2) |
| 1936 | Mel Ott, CHI | Lefty Grove, LTL (5) | Andrew Stevens, YOR (3) | Pat Malone, LTL |
| 1937 | Lou Gehrig, NYN (5) | Lefty Gomez, COR | Randy Howard, ICM (2) | Jim Tobin, BRX |
| 1938 | Jimmie Foxx, ICM (4) | Paul Derringer, BAN | Hal Ensrud, BAN | Dizzy Dean, COR |
| 1939 | Joe DiMaggio, BAK | Bob Feller, CIN | Michael Sliger, CIN (2) | Marius Russo, BAN |
| 1940 | Johnny Mize, BRX | Bob Feller, CIN (2) | Sean Cahill, BAK (2) | Joe Beggs, CHA |
| 1941 | Dolph Camilli, YOR | Bucky Walters, MIN | Jesse Squire, BRX | Johnny Murphy, CHI and Tom Earley, COR |
| 1942 | Ted Williams, LTL | Tiny Bonham, NYN | Kevin Stillman, NYN (4) | Frank Biscan, YOR |
| 1943 | Charlie Keller, YOR | Mort Cooper, CHI | Michael Sliger, CIN (3) | Al Brazle, YOR |
| 1944 | Stan Musial, CHI | Hal Newhouser, CHI | Al Ontko, MIN | Andy Karl, CHI |
| 1945 | Tommy Holmes, NYN | Hal Newhouser, CHI (2) | Jesse Squire, BRX (2) | Joe Berry, YOR |
| 1946 | Ted Williams, LTL (2) | Hal Newhouser, CHI (3) | Hal Ensrud, BAN (2) | Earl Caldwell, BAK |
| 1947 | Ted Williams, LTL (3) | Bob Feller, CIN (3) | Mark Schantz, CHI (3) | Ed Klieman, COR |
| 1948 | Stan Musial, CHI (2) | Dutch Leonard, CIN | Tom Cronk, COR (3) | Russ Christopher, LTL |
| 1949 | Ralph Kiner, LTL | Mel Parnell, CHA | Fred Antczak, CHA | Joe Page, CHA |
| 1950 | Larry Doby, CHA | Ewell Blackwell, CIN | Tom Cronk, COR (4) | Jim Hearn, COR |
| 1951 | Stan Musial, CHI (3) | Sal Maglie, COR/CHI | Sean Cahill, BAK (3) | Luis Aloma, CHI |
| 1952 | Stan Musial, CHI (4) | Mike Garcia, NYN | Andrew Stevens, YOR (4) | Stu Miller, BAK and Hoyt Wilhelm, YOR |
| 1953 | Eddie Mathews, BRX | Warren Spahn, SYR | Michael Leff, SYR | Ellis Kinder, CHI |
| 1954 | Duke Snider, NYN | Warren Spahn, SYR (2) | Kevin Stillman, NYN (5) | Harry Dorish, BAK |
| 1955 | Duke Snider, MIN (2) | Whitey Ford, BRX | Al Ontko, MIN (2) | Hersh Freeman, CHA |
| 1956 | Mickey Mantle, ICM | Herb Score, SYR | Randy Howard, ICM (3) | Ray Narleski, LTL |
| 1957 | Mickey Mantle, ICM (2) | Warren Spahn, CHA (3) | Jeff Cofield, LTL (4) | George Zuverink, MIN |
| 1958 | Willie Mays, CHA | Whitey Ford, BRX (2) | Andrew Stevens, YOR (5) | Barry Latman, BAK |
| 1959 | Hank Aaron, CHA | Camilo Pascual, CIN | Fred Antczak, CHA (2) | Larry Sherry, COR |
| 1960 | Ernie Banks, ICM | Don Drysdale, CHI | Tom Cronk, COR (5) | Lindy McDaniel, CHI |
| 1961 | Jim Gentile, COR | Warren Spahn, CHA (4) | Mark Schantz, CHI (4) | Stu Miller, BAK (2) |
| 1962 | Hank Aaron, CHA (2) | Hank Aguirre, NYN | Sean Cahill, BAK (4) | Bobby Shantz, CHI |
| 1963 | Hank Aaron, CHA (3) | Dick Ellsworth, SYR | Andrew Stevens, YOR (6) | Hoyt Wilhelm, YOR (2) |
| 1964 | Willie Mays, CHA (2) | Dean Chance, BAK | Sean Cahill, BAK (5) | Hoyt Wilhelm, YOR (3) |
| 1965 | Billy Williams, SYR | Sandy Koufax, CHI | Michael Sliger, CIN (4) | Frank Linzy, CHI |
| 1966 | Hank Aaron, CHA (4) | Sandy Koufax, CHI (2) | Randy Howard, LVM (4) | Lindy McDaniel, CHI (2) |
| 1967 | Carl Yastrzemski, YOR | Fergie Jenkins, COR | Al Ontko, MIN (3) | Ted Abernathy, LVM |
| 1968 | Willie McCovey, CHI | Bob Gibson, NYN | Kevin Stillman, NYN (6) | Frank Linzy, CHI (2) |
| 1969 | Jimmy Wynn, YOR | Bill Singer, CHI | Kevin Stillman, NYN (7) | Ken Tatum, CHI |
| 1970 | Johnny Bench, CIN | Bob Gibson, NYN (2) | Michael Leff, SYR (2) | Ken Sanders, SYR |
| 1971 | Bobby Murcer, BEA | Don Sutton, LTL | Tony Ziccardi, BEA | Ken Sanders, SYR (2) |
| 1972 | Bobby Murcer, NYN (2) | Gaylord Perry, BRX | Al Ontko, MIN (4) | Terry Forster, BRE |
| 1973 | Bobby Bonds, NYN | Bert Blyleven, BAN | Fred Antczak, CHA (3) | Sparky Lyle, NYN |
| 1974 | Joe Morgan, BRX | Nolan Ryan, BRX | Jesse Squire, BRX (3) | Max Leon, COR |
| 1975 | Joe Morgan, BRX (2) | Tom Seaver, YOR | Jeff Cofield, LTL (5) | Rich Gossage, CHI |
| 1976 | Joe Morgan, BRX (3) | Mark Littell, BAN | Tony Ziccardi, BEA (2) | Mark Littell, BAN |
| 1977 | Mike Schmidt, BAK | Bert Blyleven, BAN (2) | Ed Martin, FAI | Rich Gossage, CHI (2) |
| 1978 | Jim Rice, BRE | Dennis Eckersley, CHI | Lindsey Murdah, BRE | Doug Bair, CHI |
| 1979 | Mike Schmidt, BAK (2) | Randy Jones, BAK | Sean Cahill, BAK (6) | Aurelio Lopez, LTL |
| 1980 | George Brett, CHI | Steve Rogers, BAK | Sean Cahill, BAK (7) | Rick Camp, BAK |
| 1981 | Mike Schmidt, BAK (3) | Steve McCatty, BEA | Tony Ziccardi, BEA (3) | Rich Gossage, COR (3) |
| 1982 | Cecil Cooper, BEA | Jim Palmer, CHI | Michael Leff, SYR (3) | Rich Gossage, COR (4) |
| 1983 | Alan Trammell, BEA | Larry McWilliams, NYN | Fred Antczak, CHA (4) | Bob Stanley, BAN |
| 1984 | Ryne Sandberg, CIN | Mario Soto, CIN | Michael Sliger, CIN (5) | Dave Schmidt, CHI |
| 1985 | Dale Murphy, COR | Dwight Gooden, COR | Mark Schantz, CHI (5) | Bob James, CHI |
| 1986 | Tim Raines, LVM | Floyd Youmans, BAN | Hal Ensrud, BAN (3) | Dan Plesac, CHI |
| 1987 | Tony Gwynn, MIN | Doyle Alexander, CHI | Al Ontko, MIN (5) | Tim Burke, COR |
| 1988 | Will Clark, SYR | Pascual Perez, CIN | Michael Leff, SYR (4) | Brian Holton, CHA |
| 1989 | Robin Yount, BAK | Bret Saberhagen, CHA | Al Ontko, MIN (6) | Jeff Montgomery, MIN |