All-Star Game Results
| Year | Winner | Loser | MVP |
| 1921 | Mathewson 10 | Wagner 3 | Harry Heilmann, NYN |
| 1922 | Mathewson 12 | Wagner 5 | George Sisler, LTL |
| 1923 | Wagner 14 | Mathewson 12 | Willie Kamm, COR |
| 1924 | Mathewson 13 | Wagner 9 | Babe Ruth, CIN |
| 1925 | Wagner 9 | Mathewson 7 | Gabby Hartnett, YOR |
| 1926 | Mathewson 7 | Wagner 3 | Babe Ruth, CIN (2) |
| 1927 | Mathewson 12 | Wagner 9 | Harry Heilmann, NYN (2) |
| 1928 | Mathewson 8 | Wagner 6 | Babe Ruth, CIN (3) |
| 1929 | Mathewson 8 | Wagner 4 | Babe Ruth, CIN (4) |
| 1930 | Mathewson 14 | Wagner 2 | Lou Gehrig, NYN |
| 1931 | Wagner 5 | Mathewson 1 | Ben Chapman, YOR |
| 1932 | Wagner 7 | Mathewson 4 | Gus Mancuso, BRX |
| 1933 | Wagner 3 | Mathewson 1 | Babe Ruth, CHI (5) |
| 1934 | Mathewson 9 | Wagner 0 | Tommy Bridges, NYN |
| 1935 | Mathewson 8 | Wagner 4 | Lou Gehrig, NYN (2) |
| 1936 | Mathewson 6 | Wagner 4 | Joe DiMaggio, BAK |
| 1937 | Wagner 3 | Mathewson 1 | Earl Averill, YOR |
| 1938 | Wagner 7 | Mathewson 6 | Johnny Mize, BRX |
| 1939 | Mathewson 6 | Wagner 2 | Bob Feller, CIN |
| 1940 | Wagner 10 | Mathewson 4 | Johnny Mize, BRX (2) |
| 1941 | Mathewson 1 | Wagner 0 | Harlond Clift, BAK |
| 1942 | Wagner 4 | Mathewson 2 | Stan Hack, BRX |
| 1943 | Mathewson 6 | Wagner 5 | Mickey Vernon, BAK |
| 1944 | Mathewson 7 | Wagner 5 | Dixie Walker, NYN |
| 1945 | Mathewson 3 | Wagner 1 | Bill Salkeld, MIN |
| 1946 | Mathewson 6 | Wagner 5 (10) | Joe DiMaggio, BAK (2) |
| 1947 | Wagner 3 | Mathewson 2 | Billy Cox, CHA |
| 1948 | Wagner 9 | Mathewson 3 | Johnny Mize, COR (3) |
| 1949 | Wagner 6 | Mathewson 5 | Stan Musial, CHI |
| 1950 | Wagner 11 | Mathewson 10 (11) | Hoot Evers, COR |
| 1951 | Mathewson 5 | Wagner 1 | Ralph Kiner, ICM |
| 1952 | Mathewson 13 | Wagner 0 | Larry Doby, NYN |
| 1953 | Wagner 4 | Mathewson 3 | Richie Ashburn, BRX |
| 1954 | Mathewson 2 | Wagner 1 | Ray Boone, MIN |
| 1955 | Wagner 5 | Mathewson 3 | Al Kaline, COR |
| 1956 | Wagner 8 | Mathewson 3 | Ken Boyer, CHI |
| 1957 | Mathewson 8 | Wagner 1 | Ernie Banks, LTL |
| 1958 | Wagner 1 | Mathewson 0 | Don Zimmer, SYR |
| 1959 | Wagner 3 | Mathewson 1 | Willie Mays, CHA |
| 1960 | Mathewson 5 | Wagner 3 | Roger Maris, BAK |
| 1961 | Wagner 3 | Mathewson 2 | Willie Mays, CHA (2) |
| 1962 | Wagner 7 | Mathewson 3 | Brooks Robinson, CHI |
| 1963 | Wagner 5 | Mathewson 3 | Bill White, YOR |
| 1964 | Wagner 8 | Mathewson 2 | Hank Aaron, CHA |
| 1965 | Wagner 3 | Mathewson 2 | Johnny Edwards, BRX |
| 1966 | Mathewson 6 | Wagner 4 (10) | Joe Torre, LTL |
| 1967 | Mathewson 6 | Wagner 0 | Jim Kaat, BAK |
| 1968 | Wagner 6 | Mathewson 5 | Willie McCovey, CHI |
| 1969 | Wagner 5 | Mathewson 2 | Rico Petrocelli, CHI |
| 1970 | Wagner 7 | Mathewson 2 | Jim Hickman, BRX |
| 1971 | Wagner 2 | Mathewson 0 | Vida Blue, BRE |
| 1972 | Mathewson 6 | Wagner 2 | Lee May, NYN |
| 1973 | Mathewson 2 | Wagner 0 | George Scott, FAI |
| 1974 | Wagner 2 | Mathewson 0 | Nolan Ryan, BRX |
| 1975 | Wagner 2 | Mathewson 1 (13) | George Brett, CHI |
| 1976 | Wagner 4 | Mathewson 2 (10) | Rick Monday, SYR |
| 1977 | Mathewson 10 | Wagner 8 (12) | Larry Bowa, LTL |
| 1978 | Wagner 7 | Mathewson 6 (11) | Amos Otis, COR |
| 1979 | Mathewson 10 | Wagner 2 | Fred Lynn, LVM |
| 1980 | Wagner 4 | Mathewson 2 | Jim Bibby, CHI |
| 1981 | Wagner 4 | Mathewson 1 | Eddie Murray, CHA |
| 1982 | Wagner 8 | Mathewson 1 | Jim Palmer, CHI |